Advice Centre

Speak to a member of our specialist international team of UK family lawyers today on 0330 107 0107.

The legal complexities of child custody and child maintenance often place significant emotional and financial burdens on parents navigating family separation. The key objective in handling these matters is to provide clear guidance that aligns with the best interests of the child while ensuring that the rights of both parents are respected. This case study aims to provide a comprehensive analysis of two common issues that arise in family law: child custody and child maintenance. Both areas have their legal intricacies, and understanding the process can help parents make informed decisions when facing these challenges.

Child Custody: A Last Resort Application

In family law, child custody disputes are usually taken to court only after all other options have been tried. These include attempts at private amicable agreements, mediation, and negotiations outside of court. The importance of trying to resolve custody matters through non-legal channels cannot be overstated, as litigation can lead to long-lasting emotional stress and strain relationships further.

In cases where an amicable agreement is not possible, the court may be asked to intervene and make binding decisions regarding child custody. The key orders that a parent may request include a Child Arrangement Order. This order serves to establish the child’s living arrangements, clarifying which parent the child will reside with. The order can also outline the amount of contact or visitation the child will have with the non-residential parent, effectively dividing the time spent with each parent, provided it is safe to do so for the child. In some cases, this may result in a 50/50 custody split, but this arrangement is not guaranteed and depends on the child’s best interests and the circumstances of the family.

Furthermore, when a Child Arrangement Order is granted, it may be accompanied by a “Live With Order”, which confers some legal advantages to the residential parent over the non-residential parent.

Aside from the Child Arrangement Order, parents may seek other orders such as Specific Issue Orders or Prohibited Steps Orders. Specific Issue Orders cover matters such as the child’s schooling, medical care, religious upbringing, or even decisions about relocating the child either within England and Wales or internationally. If parents disagree about these aspects, the court can make binding decisions on such issues.

A Prohibited Steps Order, on the other hand, is often sought to prevent a parent from taking a specific action that may be harmful to the child’s welfare. For example, a parent may seek a PSO to prevent the other parent from removing the child from their care without consent or from removing the child from the country without permission.

When Court Intervention Is Necessary

The court’s role in family law matters is essential, but it is not the first step in resolving disputes. Legal practitioners always encourage clients to explore mediation and alternative dispute resolution mechanisms before resorting to court. However, there are exceptions, particularly in cases involving domestic violence. In these situations, the parent seeking a resolution is not required to prove that they have attempted to resolve the issue amicably. Provided that certain criteria is met, they can proceed directly with a court application, which expedites the resolution process to ensure the safety and well-being of the child, as well as the parent who was a victim of domestic abuse.

The court will scrutinize whether the applicant has met the necessary requirements before issuing an application. This highlights the importance of legal advice to ensure that the application is not dismissed due to procedural errors. As experienced solicitors, we work closely with clients to ensure their cases are well-prepared and that they meet all legal requirements.

Child Maintenance: A Separate Issue

One area that often surprises parents is child maintenance. Many believe that the family court will make decisions regarding maintenance as part of child custody or divorce proceedings. However, in England and Wales, child maintenance is treated separately and not dealt with during divorce, children or financial settlement proceedings. Instead, the parent with primary care of the child can either negotiate directly with the other parent or, if an agreement cannot be reached, they can seek assistance from the Child Maintenance Service (CMS). The CMS will calculate the amount of child maintenance that the non-residential parent is required to pay, based on a variety of factors including income, number of children, and the care arrangements.

This distinction between child custody and child maintenance is often misunderstood, especially among clients from other jurisdictions where these issues are handled together. For example, in some countries like Romania, child maintenance is settled during the divorce and children proceedings. In contrast, in England and Wales, it is a separate process, and the court does not typically make decisions about maintenance.

In cases where the parents are unable to reach an agreement on child maintenance, the solicitor can provide negotiation services to help facilitate a settlement. If all attempts at negotiation fail, the CMS can be asked to step in to determine the financial contributions required from the non-residential parent.

Practical Considerations and Key Takeaways

The process of addressing child custody and maintenance can be complex, and each family’s circumstances will dictate the most appropriate approach. Key points to remember are:

• Court Should Be a Last Resort: Parents should explore all non-legal avenues, including mediation, before approaching the court, except situations where the safety and welfare of the child are at risk. It is essential to demonstrate to the court that efforts to reach an agreement amicably have been made, unless domestic violence is involved or an immediate risk of harm to the child.
• Legal Orders Available to Parents: The court can issue a range of orders, including Child Arrangement Orders, Specific Issue Orders, and Prohibited Steps Orders, each addressing different aspects of child welfare and parental rights.
• Child Maintenance Is Separate from Custody Issues: Parents should be aware that child maintenance is a separate issue from child custody, and it will not be decided as part of divorce, children or financial settlement proceedings.
• International Considerations: For parents considering international relocation with their children, specific legal advice is essential to navigate the requirements imposed by both domestic and international law.
• Expert Legal Advice is Crucial: Seeking the advice of a qualified solicitor throughout this process ensures that the legal proceedings are handled efficiently and in the best interests of the child.

In conclusion, while family disputes regarding child custody and child maintenance are undoubtedly challenging, they are not insurmountable. With the right legal support, parents can find solutions that prioritize the welfare of the child while addressing the practical realities of their situation. At IMD Solicitors LLP, we are dedicated to providing our clients with the expertise and support needed to navigate these difficult matters efficiently and fairly.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal or professional advice. Please note that the law may have changed since this article was published.

To find out more about our services, visit International children matters and contact disputes section of our website.

Call us now to discuss your case 0330 107 0107 or email us at info@imd.co.uk.