Advice Centre

Speak to a member of our specialist international team of UK family lawyers today on 0330 107 0107.

Prenuptial agreements (prenups) are legal contracts entered into by couples before marriage, outlining the division of assets and financial responsibilities in case of divorce. While prenups are common in many countries, their enforceability and legal standing vary significantly from one jurisdiction to another. In particular, the treatment of prenuptial agreements in Italy and England reveals notable differences due to the distinct legal traditions, cultural attitudes, and legislative frameworks of these countries.

1. Legal Framework

Italian law is based on a civil law system, and prenuptial agreements are relatively uncommon and do not have the same widespread legal recognition as in some other jurisdictions. In Italy, marriage contracts concerning property and financial arrangements are governed by the Italian Civil Code, and spouses can choose between two main regimes: comunione dei beni (community of property) and separazione dei beni (separation of property). However, agreements specifically covering asset division upon divorce, similar to prenups, are not typically upheld by Italian courts, as the same tend to prioritize the protection of the weaker spouse.

On the contrary, the English legal system is based on common law, which offers greater flexibility and a different approach to prenuptial agreements. The courts have increasingly recognised prenups, provided they are entered into freely and fairly. However, English courts retain the discretion to set aside or modify prenups if they believe that enforcing them would lead to unfair outcomes, particularly if they would undermine the needs of children or leave one spouse in financial hardship.

2. Enforceability

Prenuptial agreements are not directly enforceable in Italian courts. Italian law does not recognize a prenup in the same way that it might be understood in other countries, like England. In divorce proceedings, the courts will generally prioritize legal protections over individual agreements. However, spouses can draft agreements during the marriage concerning the division of property and financial arrangements, but these are limited and subject to judicial review.

In contrast, prenuptial agreements in England have been given considerable legal weight. Key factors that will be taken into consideration by the Court if a dispute arises include whether both parties received independent legal advice, whether the agreement was signed well in advance of the marriage, and whether full financial disclosure was made by both parties. Even though English courts can still override prenups, they often respect them as long as the terms are deemed fair and reasonable.

3. Treatment of Postnuptial Agreements

Italian law does not have a specific framework for postnuptial agreements, and as with prenups, agreements concerning future divisions of assets upon divorce may not be upheld by the courts. Once a marriage is dissolved, the courts will make determinations about the division of property, spousal maintenance, and child support based on the needs of the parties and applicable legal principles, rather than relying on private agreements made during the marriage.

In England, the situation is very different and Courts will generally treat postnuptial agreements in much the same way as prenups, giving them considerable weight, provided they meet the same criteria of fairness and voluntariness. A key difference between England and Italy in this context is that English courts are more likely to uphold agreements made during the marriage, as long as they protect the interests of both spouses and any children involved.

4. Spousal and Child Support Considerations

Italian courts prioritize the welfare of the weaker spouse and children in divorce proceedings. Prenups that attempt to limit spousal or child support are unlikely to be enforced, as Italian law requires judges to consider the financial circumstances of both parties and to ensure that the economically weaker spouse is adequately supported. Child support, in particular, is a matter of public policy and cannot be waived or diminished by private agreements.

English courts take a similar approach in terms of protecting the interests of children, but they are more willing to respect agreements that set out spousal maintenance, provided that they do not result in one spouse being left without reasonable financial provision. Courts retain discretion to adjust spousal maintenance arrangements, even where a prenup is in place, especially if the financial needs of one party have changed significantly since the agreement was made.

5. Judicial Discretion

Judges in Italy have broad discretion when it comes to divorce settlements, and prenuptial agreements have limited influence over the court’s decision-making process. The court will generally assess the financial situation of both spouses, their needs, and their contributions during the marriage. While certain agreements regarding property regimes may be recognized, agreements that attempt to predetermine the outcome of a divorce are unlikely to be enforced.

In England, the courts also retain discretion, but there has been a shift toward respecting the autonomy of the parties to enter into prenuptial agreements. English judges will consider the fairness of the agreement at the time of the divorce, ensuring that it does not leave one party in financial hardship. However, the emphasis is on upholding the terms of the prenup as long as they were made freely, with proper legal advice and full disclosure.

Conclusion

The treatment of prenuptial agreements in Italy and England highlights significant differences, with Italy maintaining a more protective view toward spouses and children, rooted in its civil law tradition, and England adopting a more flexible, common-law approach that gives greater weight to individual autonomy and contractual freedom. While prenups are gaining recognition in both jurisdictions, their enforceability and impact on divorce settlements vary considerably, reflecting broader cultural and legal attitudes toward marriage, fairness, and financial independence.

If you are part of an international family or plan to be, it is extremely important to consider appropriate ways to protect your assets in all the involved Jurisdictions. Appropriate advice should be sought without delay as the best result may be achieved by utilizing different institutes in various Countries.

Contact Us

If you have any questions or need advice with respect to the best way to protect your assets during the marriage and /or in the event of a breakup, please do not hesitate to contact us. Our team is here to provide the support and expertise you need to navigate this process effectively.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal or professional advice. Please note that the law may have changed since this article was published.

To find out more about our services, visit International Divorce section of our website.

Call us now to discuss your case 0330 107 0107 or email us at info@imd.co.uk.